InfrastructureNews New Zealand - Aotearoa's infrastructure news for industry decision-makers
New Zealand
Hawke's Bay truck stop proposal for highly productive land declined

Hawke's Bay truck stop proposal for highly productive land declined

Thu, 19th Nov 2026 (Today)
LINDA HALL Local Democracy Reporter

A Hawke's Bay environmental advocacy group is "delighted" plans for a truck stop, service station, and retail centre on highly productive land in the Heretaunga Plains have been rejected.

Save Our Plains Group spokesperson Richard Gaddum said the decision to decline the resource consent application sends a strong message to others wanting to cover highly productive land in concrete and asphalt.

"I'm delighted," Gaddum said.

The application by Hamachek Holdings to build a truck stop, service station, retail service area, cafe and fruit shop facilities on the corner of State Highway 2 and Evenden Rd, opposite the Delegat Wines vineyard at Twyford, was publicly notified on November 5, 2025, with submissions closing on December 3, 2025.

Hamachek Holdings director Matthew Lawson said in July the closures of McCain and Wattie's plants in the region showed a key issue.

He said without infrastructure to keep up with growth and allow growers to get their produce to market efficiently, "there's no point in having fertile soil".

However, independent hearing commissioner Kitt Littlejohn, chair of the hearing panel appointed by Hastings District Council, declined the application, primarily because the applicant had not demonstrated that it met the national planning requirements for developing on highly productive agricultural land.

Littlejohn acknowledged the proposal's merits, describing it as a "well-considered and strategically useful proposal".

He said the applicant had identified "genuine needs within the regional freight network" and developed an integrated response offering substantial benefits, including improved refuelling and rest facilities, stock-effluent disposal and provision for changing transport-energy requirements.

"The proposal's evolution through the hearing process also demonstrates a serious commitment to addressing its environmental effects," he said.

However, Littlejohn said the benefits of the proposal and the attractiveness of its location could not override planning rules protecting highly productive land.

In New Zealand, Highly Productive Land (HPL) is protected by national planning rules designed to prevent the loss of valuable agricultural and horticultural land to urban development, lifestyle blocks and other non-rural uses.

He acknowledged the proposed development had significant benefits for the region and was strategically located, but said the application had to be assessed within the national and local planning framework.

"That framework does not provide a basis to approve the proposal as advanced. Consent cannot therefore be granted, despite its potential benefits."

The council received 23 submissions on the application. Four supported it, one supported it subject to conditions, 15 opposed it, one opposed it in part, and two adopted neutral or qualified positions.

The supporting submitters focused on the usefulness of the proposed facilities and their relationship with regional business and freight.

The principal concerns for those against were the permanent loss of productive soils and the introduction of a substantial commercial activity into the Plains Production Zone.

Local Democracy Reporting logo
Local Democracy Reporting is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air