'You're bloody mad': Featherston water race bylaw gets pushback
Fri, 20th Nov 2026 (Today)A bylaw that prohibits twigs from falling into a Featherston water race has faced fierce criticism from users.
Under the proposed bylaw, landowners were prohibited from allowing "cuttings, clippings, twigs, branches or any other part of any tree or plant or any part of any fence to fall into or remain in the water race".
The new bylaw was required because the former Longwood Water Race Bylaw 1936 expired in 2024, leaving no dedicated local regulatory framework for the management and protection of the network.
A report to the council said the proposed bylaw would replace the expired framework with a modern, clear and enforceable set of rules to support the ongoing operation, maintenance and long-term sustainability of the Longwood water race system.
But submitters at a hearing on Thursday said the new bylaw was an overreach that went far beyond the compliance levels of the lapsed bylaw.
Submitter Jim Hedley said the bylaw changed "workable rules into unworkable rules".
"Clause 6.2.4 prohibits allowing cuttings, clippings, twigs, branches, or any other part of tree or plant or any part of any fence to fall into or remain in the race.
"That's a twig," he said, holding up a twig.
"You're saying that has to be kept out of the race. You're bloody mad."
He said the section that mandated a 5m setback had to be kept free from vegetation of all kinds was an overstep from the previous rule that was "only about what will restrict the flow".
"Section 6 prohibits livestock from the water race ... to drink from the race, stock have to enter it, they are not elephants or giraffes.
"How do they drink from at least 5m away?"
He said it seemed the council wanted to "wrap [the water race] in cotton wool, never use it, and put all the costs onto farmers".'
"Council should not adopt this bylaw. Throw it out and start again."
Marguerite Tait-Jamieson said she was "punch drunk" by the draft bylaw.
"Between Featherston wastewater woes, an almost 200% rates increase, the felling of trees in their entirety on the Hodder Farm ... and now the draft proposal for the Longwood Water Race, I need to be thankful that the plague of boils hasn't arrived yet," Tait-Jamieson said.
She said because the bylaw had changed the water race setback from 3m from the middle of the race to 5m from an undisclosed point, landowners would "lose a quarter of an acre every 100m" along the water race.
The maximum fine for breaching the bylaw had also increased from £5 to $20,000, which Tait-Jamieson said was 20 times the previous fine in today's terms.
Submitter Garrick Emms questioned what the council's "real agenda" was behind the bylaw and believed it was "all to do with South Wairarapa District Council's consent for the Hodder Farm and discharge of wastewater in Longwood".
He and Claire Bleakley raised concerns that the Featherston wastewater treatment plant could be in breach of the conditions in the proposed Longwood Water Race bylaw.
Submitter Murray Rose, the owner of Fernside, said that the water race needed modern rules, but the proposed bylaw would "turn a 120-year-old water garden into a series of prohibited activities".
He said Fernside's streams, rills, and lake were among the first uses of the Longwood Water Race, from the 1890s.
The draft bylaw made stock water the default permitted use and Rose asked the council to make targeted amendments that recognised established "flow-through and heritage uses".
The council's agenda for the hearings meeting said the 5m setback was "generally consistent with other water race bylaws operating elsewhere in the Wairarapa".
"Officers are now aware of the impact of changing the existing setback rule of 2.7m from the centre of the water race and will consider options for council to consider at deliberations," the report said.